The mandolin reviews database is here to help educate people before they purchase an instrument. Of course, this is not meant to be a substitute for playing the instrument yourself!
89 reviews in the archive.
Where Purchased: Online direct
Year Purchased: 2014
Price Paid: 840 ($US)
I love the clear, focused sound. The M-11 is everything it's advertised to be, and more. I play a lot of Old Time and Celtic, and this is the perfect instrument for my needs. The tone is punchy enough to cut through the crowd, but still sings sweetly when need. Great sustain as well.
Sound Rating: 10
Excellent set-up. With a very, very minor tweak of the newly-installed strings, this was ready to play within minutes of arrival in the mail.
Setup Rating: 10
It's friggin' gorgeous. I paid a bit extra to have Mike add a darker stain vs. the natural clear finish he usually does on mahongany, and I really love it. Big Muddy Mandolins are hand hewn and designed to look like hand-crafted instruments.
Appearance Rating: 10
Hardware is top notch, although I may upgrade to a cast tailpiece at some point. This is a great jam instrument.
Reliability Rating: 10
Mike Dulak runs a first-rate company, and personally responds to your email questions and special requests. Great communication from start to finish. He even sent me a photo of the partially-completed instrument while he was working on it.
Customer Service: 10
Everything seems rock solid. I expect to have years of use from this well-built instrument.
Components Rating: 10
My brand new Big Muddy M-11w (wide nut) with a very unimpressed Murdock. I asked Mike to make the finish a bit darker than the normal natural tone and he did a nice stain job for a very reasonable additional fee.
Overall Rating: 10
'Flatiron Master' 1 day
'ELECTRIC MANDO BASS BOOGIE' 2 days